BIM and AEC page 5 of 5
- by Noel Susskind, PE LEED AP
8. "CAD" and "BIM" Software - 'How and Who'
BIM Software
- Autodesk's Architectural Desktop and Mechanical Desktop were developed around 1999 with the idea of designing
a building that can with other applications. Autodesk MEP continued the "Desktop" series under a different name.
- Autodesk REVIT
According to Reed Construction Data, Autodesk's RevitŪ is the dominant BIM authoring application and Revit's market
penetration into architectural firms is occurring three times faster than the market penetration of 2D CAD during the 1980s.
They said that in the next few years, the majority of all projects will be modeled in Revit. Autodesk is pushing this hard
and will begin phasing out the older products in the near future.
Products with less AEC market share than Autodesk but analogous to Autocad mechanical Desktop are:
- Bentley Microstation MEP: Adopted by Dewberry and some other prominent AE and EA firms, and other entities,
notably electric utilities, transportation departments, other civil engineering related users.
- Vectorworks (Graphisoft) Archicad: Architects and Engineers in commercial and residential construction
Purchased and merged in 2007 with Nemetschek VectorWorks.
BIM "Interoperable" Software
Collision detection
(interference checking and multi-discipline coordination across differing software platforms.
It is intended to let users of Autodesk share the model with users of competing software like Bentley and Graphisoft).
- Navisworks:
- Solibri Model Checker
Project management
- Primavera Project manager
- Microsoft Project
- Newforma
Cost Estimating
Energy modeling and Building Simulation / Performance
- Green Building Studio (Formerly GeoPraxis), bought by Autodesk in January 2008. Reads-in and supports Revit GBxml output on a web based
interface to develop sophisticated building energy models. In 2007 Revit was reportedly having output validation issues (probably data translation problems) which have since been resolved.
- Trane Trace
- Carrier HAP E20
- Plus/DOE-2/E-Quest
- IES Integrated Environmental Systems (Virtual Environment) bought by Autodesk last year. They claim Revit MEP has a 'native'
capability to calculate heating and cooling loads, but eventually it will have other features. Demonstration / beta stage
- Ecotect (also bought by Autodesk recently) - analysis on solar, thermal, shading, lighting, and airflow
HVAC Specific Simulation and Calculation Software
- Elite CHVAC load calculation
- HVAC Solutions
- Wright Software
Electrical/Lighting Design
- Design Master 3D-BIM Coordination
Design Master Electrical is capable of producing 3D models for use in clash detection with other disciplines.
Model the large components of an electrical design, such as the conduit, cable tray, and switchgear, or model
the whole plan down to the receptacles and switches.
- Automatic Code Compliance checking
Not yet ready for prime time----Inconsistent data formatting and accuracy make this problematic. The standardized IFCs
(Industry Foundation Classes) supposed to mitigate that inconsistency are slow to be adopted, especially in the US.
There is some conceptual development occurring in the form of intelligent software which can "clean up" the data.
9. Who is using BIM
75 % of all architecture firms in the US are using some kind of BIM according to Architectural Record magazine
Architecture Engineering and Construction firms leading in this approach
- Gehry Technologies
- HOK
- Gensler Architects
- HDR
- NBBJ
- Turner Construction
- Whiting-Turner Co.
- Gilbane
- Burt Hill Architects
- RTKL
- Ghafari
- RMJM Hillier Architecture
- Southland Industries
Owner /Clients
US Army Corps of Engineers (USACE)
General Services Administration (GSA)
Organizations and Agencies
- National Institute of Building Sciences (NIBS)
- National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST)
- American Institute of Architects (AIA)
- Construction Specifications Institute (CSI)
- International Code Council (ICC)
- International Centre for Facilities (ICF)
- Open Standards Consortium for Real Estate (OSCRE)
- Associated General Contractors (AGC)
- International Alliance for Interoperability (IAI)
- American Society of Heating, Refrig. and Air Conditioning Engineers(ASHRAE)
- Georgia Institute of Technology, Department of Architecture
- Stanford University
- National Institute of Standard and Technology
- Building Smart Alliance http://www.buildingsmartalliance.org/